Features > Impressions The Dance Enthusiast's Brand of Review/Thoughts on What We See
IMPRESSIONS: Amy Pivar and Seán Curran in "Together Again" at NYU Tisch Dance
Published on September 10, 2024
Benjamin Freedman, Séan Curran and Amy Pivar. Photo: Press
Choreographers/Dancers: Amy Pivar, Seán Curran, Benjamin Freedman
Rehearsal Director for Amy Pivar: Janis Brenner
Composers: The Kahalas, Billie Eilish, Alexa Sunshine Rose, Lisa Sokolov, Sol Rising, Aly Halveert, Robert Schumann
Pianist: Peter Groch
Singer: Daniel McGrew
Text: Heinrich Heine, Meghan Dunne
Lighting Design: Susan Hamburger
Costume Design for Seán Curran: Liliana Casaba
Date: September 6, 2024
It’s hard to believe Amy Pivar and Seán Curran could ever be far apart, they danced so well as a duo in the 1980s both in their own work and as founding members of the Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company. At the top of Together Again at NYU Tisch Dance, we saw them match energies, timing, and thrust in a sadly diminished performance video of their collaborative duets, Buffalos Roam and Enough, shot in the pre-digital era. Curran partnered Pivar with a deftness that revealed the depth of their connection. The murky nature of the video set us up for the impact of the live, up close and personal appearance of these two.
Amy Pivar in Detraumatizing the Archive: Mu‘u mu‘u Dances. Photo: Julie Lemberger
I can’t recall when I have cried with such a mix of catharsis and tender affection during a show. Tears are the undercurrent of this creation. Pivar choked one quick beat as she stepped forward, holding her mother’s Mu’u mu’us folded on her arm, for the close of her solo Detraumatizing the Archive: Mu‘u mu‘u Dances. Yet, she never overstated or exaggerated her feeling. She danced with a reverence for the spirit of the present moment, sweetened it with whimsy, peppered it with gestures, grounded heel-first walks, and fabric manipulation that brought to mind Martha Graham and Mummenschanz.
Amy Pivar in Detraumatizing the Archive: Mu‘u mu‘u Dances. Photo: Julie Lemberger
She spoke about the pain of her parents and the difficulty of being with them in their final years. When she curled on her side upstage, back to the audience, she made us sense how shunned she must have felt when her mother refused to sit up for five years. Dancing to the recording of a telephone order for her father at the Upper West Side deli, Zabar’s, was one brilliant means to honor how a mundane task, her weekly responsibility to shop, was his concession to her.
Amy Pivar in Detraumatizing the Archive: Mu‘u mu‘u Dances. Photo: Julie Lemberger
While Pivar was emotionally naked in her direct, impish manner, Curran and co-choreographer Benjamin Freedman were tailored and formal, arranging six chairs, 4 performers, including themselves over the course of hi Liederkreis set to Robert Schumann's Liederkreis Opus 24, (1840) with poetry written by Henrich Heine (1797-1856). Both Curran and Freedman sport kilts, knee socks, and shoes. Are they lovers, twin souls?
Benjamin Freedman, Seán Curran, and Daniel McGrew in Liederkreis. Photo: Julie Lemberger
Certainly Freedman is more than a dancer who stuns us immediately with the beauty of his every move. Curran watches Freedman with an intensity that made me flash on the ballet La Sylphide, with James, the peasant in Scotland who falls hopelessly in love with an elusive sylph. And talk about male gaze. Curran who once described himself as “a musical comedy guy, a showman always looking for jokes” sears the air with the heat of his stare.
Seán Curran, Daniel McGrew, Benjamin Freedman in Liederkreis. Photo: Julie Lemberger
The pianist Peter Broch flawlessly accompanied tenor Daniel McGrew. With his slight body, McGrew moves and sings with a rare grace and clarity. His face is so evocative and tone so supple. Curran spoke his poetic reflections during brief musical pauses. Several times, the singer, dancer, observer, facing different directions, made the same subtle hand gesture, syncing them with an emotional sting.
Benajmin Freedman. Photo: Julie Lemberger
The opening night audience was filled with other members of the original Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company, along with many modern dance luminaries. Certainly the evening made us appreciate the complexity of bonds, the contradictory confusion of them all, rich with suspension — which Freedman does so memorably, and haunting halts in which he stares out pensively. Pivar or Curran have lost none of their strength, or authenticity, only gained mastery. What an honor to witness them together again.
One stanza from Heine
Oben Lust, in Busen Tucker. Joy above, malice in my heart:
Strom, du best der Liebsten Bild! river, you are the image of my love.
Die Mann such so freundlich sicken. She can nod just as sweetly,
Lachelt such so Fromm und mild. smile just as gently and innocently
The Dance Enthusiast Shares IMPRESSIONS/our brand of review, and creates conversation.
For more IMPRESSIONS, click here.
Share your #AudienceReview of performances. Write one today!
The Dance Enthusiast - News, Reviews, Interviews and an Open Invitation for YOU to join the Dance Conversation.